Before You Hire Review

Before you commit to a hire, get clear on what your business needs.

Your team is stretched. Someone is leaving. Or the business is growing and another pair of hands feels overdue.

There may be a good reason to recruit. But before you commit salary, management time and recruitment budget, you want confidence that the role you have in mind will address the problem.

The Before You Hire Review gives you an independent assessment of one proposed hire. We examine the work behind the request, test the requirement and give you a written recommendation on how to proceed.

You leave with a clearer understanding of what needs to change, whether hiring is the right response and what to do next.

See what the review includes

Does this sound familiar?

The review is designed for SME owners and leaders facing a specific hiring decision.

It is particularly useful when:

•  Your team is under pressure, but you are unsure exactly where additional support is needed.
•  Someone is leaving and you want to check whether replacing them like for like makes sense.
•  A proposed role keeps changing as different people add their requirements.
•  Several different needs are being bundled into one job.
•  You are creating a new position and want to establish what it should achieve.
•  You want an independent second opinion before approving the recruitment budget.

You do not need a finished job description. The starting point is the business problem you want the hire to solve.

What are you asking this person to solve?

A hiring request often starts with a job title. The review starts with the work.

What needs doing? Where does it sit today? What is falling behind? Who is responsible? What would improve if you hired someone?

We examine four areas:

Capacity
Is there more work than the current team can reasonably absorb? Where is the pressure concentrated?

Capability
What skills, knowledge or experience does the work require? What is missing from the current team?

Ownership
Are responsibilities and decision-making authority clear? Is work being delayed, duplicated or left between people?

Structure
Does the way work, responsibilities or reporting lines are organised contribute to the problem?

Together, these questions help establish whether another person is needed, what their role should be and whether other changes are required.

Before You Hire Founder - Doug Caiger

Your review is carried out by Doug Caiger

I founded Before You Hire to help business leaders examine a hiring requirement before committing to recruitment.

I spent 25 years in recruitment and workforce operations, including nearly nine years at Vodafone building a contractor workforce operation from scratch. That work meant sitting with hiring managers to understand requirements, define roles and resource teams.

That experience informs the questions I ask: what work needs doing, what the business expects someone to achieve and whether the proposed role gives them a realistic chance of succeeding.

You work directly with me throughout the review.

Before You Hire does not recruit or earn placement fees. Whether the recommendation is to hire, reshape the role or take another approach, my fee is the same.

How the review works

A focused review discussion

We spend 60–90 minutes examining the proposed hire and the business need behind it.

We explore the work, current responsibilities, pressure points, missing capability and expected outcomes. Any existing job description or role brief provides useful context, but it is not a prerequisite.

Independent analysis

After the discussion, I assess the requirement across capacity, capability, ownership and structure.

This is where the proposed role is tested against the problem it is intended to solve, including the assumptions, gaps and risks that could affect the hiring decision.

Written findings and recommendations

Within five working days of the review discussion, you receive written findings explaining the requirement, the evidence behind the recommendation and the practical next steps.

The discussion is the starting point. The analysis and written outputs turn it into a recommendation you can use.

Before You Hire Review Process

What You Receive

Your review includes three written outputs, plus a Recruitment-Ready Brief where the recommendation supports hiring.

1. Hiring Hypothesis
A clear statement of what the proposed role is expected to solve and what must improve for it to be the right decision.

This gives you a clear basis for judging whether the role addresses the business need.

2. Work Map
A view of the work behind the proposed hire: who owns it today, where the handovers and pressure points are, and what capability it requires.

This shows where support is needed and where existing arrangements may also need to change.

3. Recommendation
Proceed, Redesign, Strengthen or Pause, with the findings, key risks and practical next steps.

You can use it to explain the decision internally and identify what needs to happen before moving forward.

Recruitment-Ready Brief, where hiring is recommended
A brief setting out the role’s purpose, responsibilities, required capability and expected outcomes.

It reflects any recommended changes and can be used with your internal hiring team or chosen recruitment partner.

The Before You Hire Review outputs: Hiring Hypothesis, Work Map, Decision and Recommendations, and Recruitment-Ready Brief

A clear recommendation to inform your decision

Your review concludes with one of four recommendations.

Proceed

The evidence supports the hire. You have a clearer requirement and a brief to take into recruitment.

Redesign

A hire may be appropriate, but the proposed role needs to change. The findings explain what should be revised and why.

Strengthen

The need is better addressed through existing capability, redistribution of work, development or another non-permanent response.

Pause

There are unresolved questions or conditions to address before committing to a hire. The findings explain what needs attention first.

You retain the decision. The review gives you an independent assessment to make it with greater confidence.

Before You Hire Review

£2,500.00 + VAT (Fixed Fee)

A defined scope. A fixed fee.

The Before You Hire Review covers one proposed hiring decision and includes:

• A 60–90 minute review discussion.
• Independent analysis of the requirement.
• AA written Hiring Hypothesis and Work Map.
• A recommendation explaining the findings, risks and next steps.
• A recruitment-ready brief where the recommendation supports hiring.

Written findings are delivered within five working days of the review discussion.

The review focuses on the requirement behind the proposed hire. Recruitment delivery, implementation and wider organisational work fall outside its scope.

If the findings identify a broader issue, I will explain it and recommend what needs attention. Any further support would be discussed and agreed separately. There is no obligation to buy additional services.

Not yet at a specific hire?

If the business is experiencing workforce pressure but you do not yet have a specific role to review, the free 5-minute Workforce Health Check helps indicate whether the pressure is most strongly connected to Capacity, Capability, Ownership or Structure.

Start the Workforce Health Check

Federation of Small Business Member Logo
Thames Valley Chamber of Commerce Member Logo
TEAM Member Logo